Clients Who Follow: Will Minnesota Strike Down “Non-Service” Clauses?

Follow us on LinkedIn to see future News.

Rutu Patel

October 26, 2026

Last year, Minnesota banned non-competition agreements.  Now, Minnesota also may limit how far employers can go in protecting their client relationships.  On September 30, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota asked the Minnesota Supreme Court to decide whether a restrictive covenant is unenforceable when it bars a “fiduciary” (such as a financial advisor, doctor, or lawyer) from servicing clients who independently (without solicitation) decide to follow them to a new firm.  Ballast Advisors, LLC v. Peterson, No. 23-CV-3769 (D. Minn. Sept. 30, 2026).

The Dispute

In Ballast, a financial advisor (Peterson) left the firm, at least 45 clients followed, and the former employer (Ballast) sued to enforce restrictive covenants.  At the heart of the dispute was a clause in the financial advisor’s employment agreement labeled “Non-solicitation.”  It did two things: (1) it barred the financial advisor from soliciting firm clients; and (2) it barred him from providing services to any firm client for two years, “regardless of whether [he] solicited the client or even had any contact with the client” – which Peterson denied doing.  The court called the second restriction a “non-service provision.”

The U.S. District Court’s Concern

Traditionally, Minnesota courts apply a reasonableness test in deciding whether to enforce a post-employment restriction against a former employer, weighing only the employer’s legitimate business interests against the employee’s right to work.  Applying that test to a “non-service provision” concerned Chief Judge Patrick Schiltz who noted that it “ignores the interests of the employee’s former clients,” who never agreed to the restriction.  The court pointed to other jurisdictions that treat covenants affecting fiduciary relationships differently from ordinary commercial ones.

Other Jurisdictions Have Drawn the Line

In asking the Minnesota Supreme Court to weigh in (by certifying the question), the District Court pointed to decisions from other jurisdictions that treat covenants affecting fiduciary relationships differently from ordinary commercial ones:

  • Lawyers: New Jersey, Massachusetts, and Nebraska courts refuse to apply commercial standards to restrictions on lawyers, citing clients’ freedom to choose counsel.
  • Doctors: Arizona and Ohio courts treat the doctor-patient relationship as entitled to special protection.
  • Advisors and accountants: Federal courts in New York, California, and Iowa have limited restrictions that go beyond active solicitation or that restrict access to the advisor a client chooses.

Because Minnesota courts have not addressed the question head on, and because it “is certain to recur,” the District Court stayed the case until the Minnesota Supreme Court has a chance to decide whether a non-service provision goes too far.  A similar request to evaluate the enforceability of a non-service provision also has been filed in a case pending in the Southern District of Iowa.  Choreo, LLC v. Lors, No. 4:25-CV-0077-SMR-SBJ, ECF No. 172-2 at 1 (S.D. Iowa Mar. 16, 2026).

Other Lessons from the Decision

  • Consideration: A $500 bonus paid by Ballast to all employees months before Peterson signed the agreement was not valid consideration for the restrictive covenants. But a retirement benefit tied to the agreement was sufficient.
  • Damages: To recover lost profits, the employer must show client by client that a specific breach caused a specific client to leave. The fact that clients departed during the restricted period is not enough.

Takeaways for Minnesota Employers

  • Review your client-based restrictive covenants now, especially for financial advisors, health care providers, and other professionals in relationships of trust. Consider whether a stand-alone, clearly drafted non-solicitation provision, which remains permitted under Minnesota’s non-compete statute, better protects your interests as compared to a broad “non-service” restriction.
  • Provide real, bargained-for consideration when you ask current employees to sign new restrictive covenants. Document the exchange at the time of signing.
  • If an employee departs and clients follow, act quickly to preserve evidence of solicitation and to tie each lost client to specific conduct. Your ability to prove damages may depend on it.

Rubin Fortunato will continue to monitor the Minnesota Supreme Court’s response to the certified question.

 

The author of this article, Rutu Patel, is a member of the Bars of New Jersey and Pennsylvania.  This article is designed to provide one perspective regarding recent legal developments, and is not intended to serve as legal advice in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, or any other jurisdiction, nor does it establish an attorney-client relationship with any reader of the article where one does not exist.  Always consult an attorney with specific legal issues.

 
© 2026 Rubin Fortunato. All rights reserved. Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Sitemap
Lisi
Rubin Fortunato
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.